No. 35588 (Amendment): Section R81-1-6. Violation Schedule

(Amendment)

DAR File No.: 35588
Filed: 12/30/2011 03:24:46 PM

RULE ANALYSIS

Purpose of the rule or reason for the change:

This proposed rule amendment is required because substantive changes to the violation grid have been made that establish or adjust the degree of seriousness of a violation. The substantive changes are the result of the recodification of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act from Title 32A to 32B (S.B. 167 passed in the 2010 General Session) which was effective 07/01/2011, and new and modified provisions of Title 32B (S.B. 314 and S.B. 2002 passed by the 2011 Legislature). The updated violation grid is incorporated by reference as part of this rule as the "November 2011 edition".

Summary of the rule or change:

The statutory references for each violation have been updated from Title 32A to 32B due to the recodification of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act (S.B. 167 passed in the 2010 General Session) which was effective 07/01/2011 and each section of the grid is renamed and renumbered to match up with Title 32B. Violations have been added to coincide with the new and modified provisions of Title 32B (S.B. 314 and S.B. 2002 passed by the 2011 Legislature) for each license type. Three new sections have been added: one for the Resort License created by S.B. 187 passed by the 2009 Legislature, and two for the new licenses created by S.B. 314, passed by the 2011 Legislature; Beer Only Restaurant, and Reception Center. These new sections contain analogous violations that pertain to existing licenses and new violations specific to the new licenses. Degrees of seriousness have been established for the newly added violations that are analogous to the degrees of seriousness for existing violations. For example: the penalty for allowing consumption during prohibited hours has existed in the club section in previous editions of the grid with a degree of "serious". S.B. 314 made this a violation for all retail licenses and event permits, so the violation has been added to each retail and event permit license section in the grid with an assigned degree of "serious". All degrees of seriousness for trade practice violations in the Local Industry Representative section have been changed to "grave" as required in Subsection R81-1-6(4)(d) of the rule and to correct an error in the previous edition of the violation grid. Degrees of seriousness of violations that existed in the previous edition of the violation grid have not been changed. All violations with the established degrees of seriousness that have been added to the violation grid are highlighted in yellow in the edition of the violation grid document that is incorporated by reference.

State statutory or constitutional authorization for this rule:

• Section 32B-2-202
• Section 32B-3-203
• Section 32B-3-204
• Section 32B-3-205

This rule or change incorporates by reference the following material:

• Updates Alcoholic Beverage Control Commission Violation Grid, published by Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, January 2012

Anticipated cost or savings to:

the state budget:

None--The cost to the state is in holding violation hearings. The cost is the same regardless of the classification of the violation.

local governments:

None--This rule amendment affects the DABC's adjudication of violations. The proceedings take place on the state level and do not affect local governments.

small businesses:

Many licensees and permitees are small businesses with fewer than 50 employees. Though it is not possible to determine an exact dollar amount, this amendment may affect those restaurants, clubs, and other DABC licensees and permitees that are cited for a violation and may have to suffer a fine and or a suspension.

persons other than small businesses, businesses, or local governmental entities:

Though it is not possible to determine an exact dollar amount, this amendment may affect employees of licensees and permitees who are cited for a violation and who may have to pay a fine or serve a suspension of employment.

Compliance costs for affected persons:

None--There are no compliance costs involved in this proposed amendment. Existing adjudication procedures and violation penalty ranges have not been modified by this amendment.

Comments by the department head on the fiscal impact the rule may have on businesses:

There will be a fiscal impact on businesses cited for a violation of The Alcoholic Beverage Control Act if the adjudication of a violation results in a fine and/or suspension. The resultant fine and/or suspension will negatively affect businesses and their employees. However, this fiscal impact was contemplated by legislation that necessitated this proposed rule amendment (S.B. 187 passed by the 2009 Legislature; S.B. 167 passed by the 2010 Legislature; and S.B. 314 and S.B. 2002 passed by the 2011 Legislature).

Francine Giani, Executive Director

The full text of this rule may be inspected, during regular business hours, at the Division of Administrative Rules, or at:

Alcoholic Beverage Control
Administration
1625 S 900 W
SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84104-1630

Direct questions regarding this rule to:

• Earl Dorius at the above address, by phone at 801-977-6800, by FAX at 801-977-6889, or by Internet E-mail at [e-mail]

Interested persons may present their views on this rule by submitting written comments to the address above no later than 5:00 p.m. on:

02/14/2012

This rule may become effective on:

02/21/2012

Authorized by:

Francine Giani, Executive Director

RULE TEXT

R81. Alcoholic Beverage Control, Administration.

R81-1. Scope, Definitions, and General Provisions.

R81-1-6. Violation Schedule.

(1) Authority. This rule is pursuant to Sections 32B-2-202(1)(c)(i), 32B-2-202(1) and (3), 32B-2-202(2)(b) and (c), and 32B-3-101 to -207. These provisions authorize the commission to establish criteria and procedures for imposing sanctions against licensees and permittees and their officers, employees and agents who violate statutes and commission rules relating to alcoholic beverages. For purposes of this rule, holders of certificates of approval are also considered licensees. The commission may revoke or suspend the licenses or permits, and may impose a fine against a licensee or permittee in addition to or in lieu of a suspension. The commission also may impose a fine against an officer, employee or agent of a licensee or permittee. Violations are adjudicated under procedures contained in Section 32B-3-101 to -207 and disciplinary hearing Section R81-1-7.

(2) General Purpose. This rule establishes a schedule setting forth a range of penalties which may be imposed by the commission for violations of the alcoholic beverage laws. It shall be used by department decision officers in processing violations, and by presiding officers in charging violations, in assisting parties in settlement negotiations, and in recommending penalties for violations. The schedule shall be used by the commission in rendering its final decisions as to appropriate penalties for violations.

(3) Application of Rule.

(a) This rule governs violations committed by all commission licensees and permittees and their officers, employees and agents except single event permittees. Violations by single event permittees and their employees and agents are processed under Section 32B-9-204 and -305.

(b) This rule does not apply to situations where a licensee or permittee fails to maintain the minimum qualifications provided by law for holding a license or permit. These might include failure to maintain a bond or insurance, or a conviction for a criminal offense that disqualifies the licensee or permittee from holding the license or permit. These are fundamental licensing and permitting requirements and failure to maintain them may result in immediate suspension or forfeiture of the license or permit. Thus, they are not processed in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act, Title 63G, Chapter 4 or Section R81-1-7. They are administered by issuance of an order to show cause requiring the licensee or permittee to provide the commission with proof of qualification to maintain their license or permit.

(c) If a licensee or permittee has not received a letter of admonishment, as defined in Sections R81-1-2 and R81-1-7(2)(b), or been found by the commission to be in violation of Utah statutes or commission rules for a period of 36 consecutive months, its violation record shall be expunged for purposes of determining future penalties sought. The expungement period shall run from the date the last offense was finally adjudicated by the commission.

(d) In addition to the penalty classifications contained in this rule, the commission may:

(i) upon revocation of a license or permit, take action to forfeit the bond of any licensee or permittee;

(ii) prohibit an officer, employee or agent of a licensee or permittee from serving, selling, distributing, manufacturing, wholesaling, warehousing, or handling alcoholic beverages in the course of employment with any commission licensee or permittee for a period determined by the commission;

(iii) order the removal of a manufacturer's, supplier's or importer's products from the department's sales list and a suspension of the department's purchase of those products for a period determined by the commission if the manufacturer, supplier, or importer directly committed the violation, or solicited, requested, commanded, encouraged, or intentionally aided another to engage in the violation.

(iv) require a licensee to have a written responsible alcohol service plan as provided in R81-1-24.

(e) When the commission imposes a fine or administrative costs, it shall establish a date on which the payment is due. Failure of a licensee or permittee or its officer, employee or agent to make payment on or before that date shall result in the immediate suspension of the license or permit or the suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent to serve, sell, distribute, manufacture, wholesale, warehouse or handle alcoholic beverages with any licensee or permittee until payment is made. Failure of a licensee or permittee to pay a fine or administrative costs within 30 days of the initial date established by the commission shall result in the issuance of an order to show cause why the license or permit should not be revoked and the licensee's or permittee's compliance bond forfeited. The commission shall consider the order to show cause at its next regularly scheduled meeting.

(f) Violations of any local ordinance are handled by each individual local jurisdiction.

(4) Penalty Schedule. The department and commission shall follow these penalty range guidelines:

(a) Minor Violations. Violations of this category are lesser in nature and relate to basic compliance with the laws and rules. If not corrected, they are sufficient cause for action. Penalty range: Verbal warning from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) to revocation of the license or permit and/or up to a $25,000 fine. A record of any letter of admonishment shall be included in the licensee's or permittee's and the officer's, employee's or agent's violation file at the department to establish a violation history.

(i) First occurrence involving a minor violation: the penalty shall range from a verbal warning from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s), which is documented to a letter of admonishment to the licensee or permittee and the officer, employee or agent involved. Law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall notify management of the licensee or permittee when verbal warnings are given.

(ii) Second occurrence of the same type of minor violation: a written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department. The penalty shall range from a $100 to $500 fine for the licensee or permittee, and a letter of admonishment to a $25 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iii) Third occurrence of the same type of minor violation: a one to five day suspension of the license or permit and employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $200 to $500 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $50 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iv) More than three occurrences of the same type of minor violation: a six day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and a six to ten day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $500 to $25,000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $75 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(v) If more than one violation is charged during the same investigation, the penalty shall be the sum of the days of suspension and/or the monetary penalties for each of the charges in their respective categories. If other minor violations are discovered during the same investigation, a verbal warning shall be given for each violation on a first occurrence. If the same type of violation is reported more than once during the same investigation, the violations shall be charged as a single occurrence.

(b) Moderate Violations. Violations of this category demonstrate a general disregard for the laws or rules. Although the gravity of the acts are not viewed in the same light as in the serious and grave categories, they are still sufficient cause for action. Penalty range: Written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department on the first occurrence. The penalty shall range from a letter of admonishment to revocation of the license or permit and/or up to a $25,000 fine.

(i) First occurrence involving a moderate violation: a written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department. The penalty shall range from a letter of admonishment to a $1000 fine for the licensee or permittee, and a letter of admonishment to a $50 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(ii) Second occurrence of the same type of moderate violation: a three to ten day suspension of the license or permit and a three to ten day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $500 to $1000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $75 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iii) Third occurrence of the same type of moderate violation: a ten to 20 day suspension of the license or permit and a ten to 20 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $1000 to $2000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $100 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iv) More than three occurrences of the same type of moderate violation: a 15 day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and a 15 to 30 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $2000 to $25,000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $150 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(v) If more than one violation is charged during the same investigation, the penalty shall be the sum of the days of suspension and/or the sum of the monetary penalties for each of the charges in their respective categories.

(vi) If the same type of violation is reported more than once during the same investigation, the violations shall be charged as a single occurrence.

(c) Serious Violations. Violations of this category directly or indirectly affect or potentially affect the public safety, health and welfare, or may involve minors. Penalty range: Written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department on the first occurrence. The penalty shall range from a five day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and/or up to a $25,000 fine.

(i) First occurrence involving a serious violation: written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department. The penalty shall range from a five to 30 day suspension of the license or permit and a five to 30 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $500 to $3000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $100 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(ii) Second occurrence of the same type of serious violation: a ten to 90 day suspension of the license or permit and a ten to 90 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $1000 to $9000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $150 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iii) More than two occurrences of the same type of serious violation: a 15 day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and a 15 to 120 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $9000 to $25,000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $500 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iv) If more than one violation is charged during the same investigation, the penalty shall be the sum of the days of suspension and/or the sum of the monetary penalties for each of the charges in their respective categories.

(v) If the same type of violation is reported more than once during the same investigation, the violations shall be charged as a single occurrence.

(d) Grave Violations. Violations of this category pose or potentially pose, a grave risk to public safety, health and welfare, or may involve lewd acts prohibited by title 32B, fraud, deceit, willful concealment or misrepresentation of the facts, exclusion of competitors' products, unlawful tied house trade practices, commercial bribery, interfering or refusing to cooperate with authorized officials in the discharge of their duties, unlawful importations, or industry supplying liquor to persons other than the department and military installations. Penalty range: Written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department on the first occurrence. The penalty shall range from a ten day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and/or up to a $25,000 fine.

(i) First occurrence involving a grave violation: written investigation report from law enforcement or department compliance officer(s) shall be forwarded to the department. The penalty shall range from a ten day suspension to revocation of the license or permit and a 10 to 120 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent, and/or a $1000 to $25,000 fine to the licensee or permittee and up to a $300 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(ii) More than one occurrence of the same type of grave violation: a fifteen day suspension to revocation of the license or permit, and a 15 to 180 day suspension of the employment of the officer, employee or agent and/or a $3000 to $25,000 fine for the licensee or permittee and up to a $500 fine for the officer, employee or agent.

(iii) If more than one violation is charged during the same investigation, the penalty shall be the sum of the days of suspension and/or the sum of the monetary penalties for each of the charges in their respective categories.

(iv) If the same type of violation is reported more than once during the same investigation, the violations shall be charged as a single occurrence.

(e) The following table summarizes the penalty ranges contained in this section of the rule for licensees and permittees.

 

TABLE

Violation        Warning         Fine       Suspension    Revoke

Degree and    Verbal/Written   $ Amount     No. of Days  License

Frequency



Minor

1st              X     X

2nd                         100 to    500

3rd                         200 to    500     1 to 5

Over 3                      500 to 25,000     6 to           X



Moderate

1st                     X        to  1,000

2nd                          500 to  1,000     3 to 10

3rd                        1,000 to  2,000    10 to 20

Over 3                     2,000 to 25,000    15 to          X



Serious

1st                          500 to  3,000     5 to 30

2nd                        1,000 to  9,000    10 to 90

Over 2                     9,000 to 25,000    15 to          X



Grave

1st                        1,000 to 25,000    10 to          X

Over 1                     3,000 to 25,000    15 to          X

 

(f) The following table summarizes the penalty ranges contained in this section of the rule for officers, employees or agents of licensees and permittees.

 

TABLE

Violation           Warning             Fine         Suspension

Degree and      Verbal/Written       $ Amount        No. of Days

Frequency



Minor

1st               X       X

2nd                       X            to  25

3rd                                    to  50         1 to 5

Over 3                                 to  75         6 to 10



Moderate

1st                       X            to  50

2nd                                    to  75         3 to 10

3rd                                    to 100        10 to 20

Over 3                                 to 150        15 to 30



Serious

1st                                    to 100         5 to 30

2nd                                    to 150        10 to 90

Over 2                                 to 500        15 to 120



Grave

1st                                    to 300        10 to 120

Over 1                                 to 500        15 to 180

 

(5) Aggravating and Mitigating Circumstances. The commission and presiding officers may adjust penalties within penalty ranges based upon aggravating or mitigating circumstances.

(a) Examples of mitigating circumstances are:

(i) no prior violation history;

(ii) good faith effort to prevent a violation;

(iii) existence of written policies governing employee conduct;

(iv) extraordinary cooperation in the violation investigation that shows the licensee or permittee and the officer, employee or agent of the licensee or permittee accepts responsibility; and

(v) there was no evidence that the investigation was based on complaints received or on observed misconduct of others, but was based solely on the investigating authority creating the opportunity for a violation.

(b) Examples of aggravating circumstances are:

(i) prior warnings about compliance problems;

(ii) prior violation history;

(iii) lack of written policies governing employee conduct;

(iv) multiple violations during the course of the investigation;

(v) efforts to conceal a violation;

(vi) intentional nature of the violation;

(vii) the violation involved more than one patron or employee;

(viii) the violation involved a minor and, if so, the age of the minor; and

(ix) whether the violation resulted in injury or death.

(6) Violation Grid. Any proposed substantive change to the violation grid that would establish or adjust the degree of seriousness of a violation shall require rulemaking in compliance with title 63G-3, the Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act. A violation grid describing each violation of the alcoholic beverage control laws, the statutory and rule reference, and the degree of seriousness of each violation is available for public inspection in the department's administrative office. A copy will be provided upon request at reproduction cost. It is entitled "Alcoholic Beverage Control Commission Violation Grid" [(May 2010 edition)](January 2012 edition) and is incorporated by reference as part of this rule.

 

KEY: alcoholic beverages

Date of Enactment or Last Substantive Amendment: [October 1, 2011]2012

Notice of Continuation: May 10, 2011

Authorizing, and Implemented or Interpreted Law: 32B-2-201(10); 32B-2-202; 32B-3-203(3)(c); 32B-1-305; 32B-1-306; 32B-1-307; 32B-1-607; 32B-1-304(1)(a); 32B-6-702; 32B-6-805(3); 32B-9-204(4); 32B-4-414(1)(b) and (c)

 

---